Notice God's unutterable waste of saints, according to the judgment of the world. God plants His saints in the most useless places. We say - God intends me to be here because I am so useful. Jesus never estimated His life along the line of the greatest use. God puts His saints where they will glorify Him, and we are no judges at all of where that is. ~Oswald Chambers, My Utmost For His Highest, August 10

Tuesday, September 09, 2008

Women in Public Office, Part I

It is time.

I'm weary of reading blogs written by well-meaning Christian women which are either tearing down VP nominee Sarah Palin or using Scripture to "prove" why women cannot hold public office.

I've kept my peace since August 29 when McCain announced his pick. I admire my own restraint. Don't you? Don't you see lots of personal growth in that I've kept my rant to myself thus far?

Well, get ready--because I'm ready!


I've read on I don't know how many blogs (blogs which I really like, by the way. Blogs which you can probably find in my blog roll. Blogs written by lovely Christian women with whom I have a lot in common.) how the Bible teaches male-headship and forbids a woman from serving as a civil magistrate. Just today I read an article here that gave the following Scriptures as evidence: Ex. 18:21, Pro. 31:23, 1 Tim. 2:12. Here's the exact quote:

"Christians across the nation are cheering the entrance of Mrs. Palin, forgetting that, according to the biblical qualifications for a civil magistrate, she as a woman is not qualified to hold this office (Ex. 18:21, Pro. 31:23, 1 Tim. 2:12). We believe that Mrs. Palin’s appointment as civil ruler, and indeed the feminist strides that made it possible, are a judgment from God (Isa. 3:12)."

And while I appreciate and agree with the Visionary Daughters conclusion that we need to pray for stronger men and raise godly sons with integrity, I do object to Scripture being used so out of context.

From the above mentioned article, "The example of the prophetess Deborah, though set in a time of more severe judgment than ours, gives interesting insights. She was living in a time when “the children of Israel again did evil in the sight of the Lord” (Judges 4:1), “Village life ceased” (Judges 5:7), and the leaders had not been leading (Judges 5:2). Despite the desperation of the time, Deborah clearly did not become a civil magistrate or “judge” in the modern sense of the word, nor did she run for any kind of office, nor did she sit in the gates (Judges 4:5)."

Let's begin with how Deborah "judged" if she supposedly did not do so in a civil sense.

One of the verses given to "prove" that civil leaders had to be men is Exodus 18:21. However, Exodus 18:22 says that those who Moses appointed were to judge. It is the exact same Hebrew word as is used in Judges 4:4 explaining that Deborah judged Israel. It goes on to say in Judges 4:5 that the children of Israel came to Deborah for "judgment." The meaning of that word in Hebrew from the Strong's concordance is as follows:

1) judgment, justice, ordinance
a) judgment
1) act of deciding a case
2) place, court, seat of judgment
3) process, procedure, litigation (before judges)
4) case, cause (presented for judgment)
5) sentence, decision (of judgment)
6) execution (of judgment)
7) time (of judgment)
b) justice, right, rectitude (attributes of God or man)
c) ordinance
d) decision (in law)
e) right, privilege, due (legal)
f) proper, fitting, measure, fitness, custom, manner, plan

It certainly does seem that Deborah judged in a civil sense. It is absolutely clear that she was an appointed judge over an entire nation! The Visionary Daughter article says, "She was living in a time when “the children of Israel again did evil in the sight of the Lord” (Judges 4:1), “Village life ceased” (Judges 5:7), and the leaders had not been leading (Judges 5:2)." But you cannot stop there! The verse says, "the villages ceased, they ceased in Israel, until that I Deborah arose, that I arose a mother in Israel." From this we see that Deborah was the ANSWER to the sin in the land, not a result of it. And it also interesting to note that she was a married woman, apparently with children. It does not say she was a mother TO Israel. It says she was a mother IN Israel.

Here's an interesting verse, part of the praise and prophecy that went forth after the victory of Deborah and Barak: "Then he made him that remaineth have dominion over the nobles among the people: the LORD made me have dominion over the mighty." (Judges 5:13)

From the Hebrew:

Dominion:
1) to rule, have dominion, dominate, tread down
a) (Qal) to have dominion, rule, subjugate
b) (Hiphil) to cause to dominate
2) to scrape out
a) (Qal) to scrape, scrape out

Nobles:
1) great, majestic
a) of waters of sea
b) of a tree
c) of kings, nations, gods
2) great one, majestic one
a) of nobles, chieftains, servants

Mighty (as a noun):
strong man, brave man, mighty man

among the people:
1) nation, people
a) people, nation
b) persons, members of one's people, compatriots, country-men
2) kinsman, kindred

I think it abundantly clear that Deborah did indeed rule in a governmental sense.

What about Exodus 18, then? This verse does not say that those rulers could not be women.

The Hebrew word used for man in this verse does not translate "male." It literally means:

1) man, mortal man, person, mankind
a) of an individual
b) men (collective)
c) man, mankind

So, Moses was to appoint individuals (mankind, humans) to judge.

Exegesis of Proverbs 31:23 and 1 Timothy 2:12 in Part II.
(Please feel free to leave comments or questions. But, remember to be kind to one another.)

10 comments:

Wilderness Mama said...

Excellent post! I tend to be in the middle of this....not a feminist but not in agreement with the "women can't be in office" side either. You have comfirmed that I am right where I need to be. I think Sarah Palin will be so great, just what this country needs!

Marianne Elixir said...

Love it. Don't keep these rants to yourself! I will try to squeeze in time for further thoughts on this topic later...this proves to be a crazy week (catering my first wedding).

Lady Dorothy said...

Thank you!

Catherine R. said...

Like you, I have had a tough time with this one, all of a sudden wondering if I'm on the same page as people I normally always am with major stuff.

I find it hard not to be enthusiastic about her, then I started doubting myself when I read all the arguments against her and I honestly don't feel at ease yet.

Some of the stuff I've read against her has struck me as over the top and made me wonder. But thanks for discussing it : )

Zimms Zoo said...

I have to say I was on the fence too on this subject. So I talked to my husband about it. Funny that he said almost the exact same thing that you said. He thinks we should vote for her.

He also said that all the legalistic type people that keep saying she can't hold office (or shouldn't) only use OT references. Mainly because it uses man. But that man didn't mean just a male. Exactly your point.

How funny to read this today after us having this conversation last night. Thanks for all the food for thought.

amy in peru said...

I'm just so excited about Mrs. Palin! Both my husband and I are. I'm excited to see what will happen.

You won my contest!!! I need you to contact me with your info to get that TOS subscription to you ASAP!

Yay!

:)

Amy
Trujillo, Peru

Anonymous said...

(I'm having internet connection problems. If this is a repeat post, please delete it!!)

I'm with you, Daja.

I totally get the sense of "for such a time as this" with Palin.

I'm sure you've seen that all the polls since the RNC have shown McCain-Palin leading Obama-Biden, or at very least, tied with him. Now, that doesn't guarantee success on Election Day, but it looks a lot better than McCain trailing by 4-8% before the RNC and his announcement of Palin. And, if absolutely nothing else, I say that it was worth it to choose Palin just so that Obama won't get elected. Many of his ideas are, to me, just so wrong and it seems like, yes, he would lead America to change, but to change on the wrong path.... a path that leads to destruction.

However, I support Palin as VP not just because she's the antidote to Obama, but because she does appear to have all the qualities (and beliefs, and political stances) that would bring good change to our dear country.

I have minor reservations about her being able to handle the position while mothering four children who are at home. However, she's not me. I couldn't do it, but it's very likely that she can.

Plus... although the VP is a full-time job, it's surely not as time-demanding as the presidency. Of course, as VP, she may end up, in a tragedy, as the President. But, it seems to me that the role of VP would be inherently a lot more flexible than that of the Presidency -- the President needs to be visible nearly 100% of the time, but not so much for the VP.

Hope all that makes sense.

Aunt Julie said...

Weren't there strong women in The Bible, too? We must remind our Christian friends that we're living in the 21st Century!

Happy Elf Mom (Christine) said...

OK, could you please look at I Timothy 3:12 and tell me what you think... I'm not trying to be insulting as I'm sure you've heard this verse a million times, but I'm just asking. I'm thinking that if a CHURCH leader has to be a man, or the pastor has to be a man, wouldn't it stand to reason that major civil leaders should have to be men?

Though of course, I tend to disagree with the Christian who is even more conservative than me and say it's always sin when a woman works. That's just silly. But the feminist ideal that women and men are just alike and that women can hold full-time jobs and the children will be just fine doesn't follow either. (I find myself sounding rather wishy-washy on this. But having travelled internationally, I think you see the fallacy in the argument that God will just take care of you if you stay home and wait for the husband to magically bring home lotsa money. Sometimes God provides differently for families depending on where they live.)

I personally get nervous about people thinking of electing women (especially married with small children) to higher office just as a matter of course. I always read things about Deborah and Queen Esther to be more of the exception, noting that of course the trouble is, how do you know when it's an exception?

Daja, I really like you and your blog. I appreciate that the very few times we disagree (or is this a first?) we have done it with friendliness and respect. I don't see what you've posted as a "rant" at all.

Oo, we disagreed again LOL.

Can I also ask if this opinion of yours, that women can hold higher office, would extend to "women SHOULD hold office, and I'd want my daughter to do this if she's so inclined?" I'm trying to first off see where the boundary is in your thinking and biblically howcome.

HOPEFULLY as you are reading this, you come away hearing a respectful tone in your head because that's how it's been typed. Thanks for being my bloggy friend.

:]

Gombojav Tribe said...

Mrs. C.,

I will get to I Tim. 3 by and by. This series may be 12 parts! LOL

Suffice it to say, that I do believe it is OK for a woman to be a pastor. I am one! I was a full-time pastor in Mongolia when I lived there, with my husband I'm overseeing a church there now, and it's likely that when we ordain a pastor over our new church it will be a woman.

Until I get to blogging on I Tim. 3, please read Margaret Fell's essay that I linked to in this post.

Blessings,
Daja