Notice God's unutterable waste of saints, according to the judgment of the world. God plants His saints in the most useless places. We say - God intends me to be here because I am so useful. Jesus never estimated His life along the line of the greatest use. God puts His saints where they will glorify Him, and we are no judges at all of where that is. ~Oswald Chambers, My Utmost For His Highest, August 10

Friday, January 23, 2009

It begins....

Today, one day after the historic Roe v. Wade decision, President Obama lifted the Executive order put in place by President Bush, that bans the federal funding of abortions abroad.

I guess he promised change and he's following through.

Now your hard-earned tax dollars will fund the slaughter of babies in third world countries.


27 comments:

Leona said...

SO SO SAD:( HORRIBLE!!!!!

Sue said...

Awful! I am so heavy hearted.

Unknown said...

Liberal friends are always saying the GOP has done NOTHING to end abortion so we may as well vote for the poor via the Party of the Good People. We are about to see rescinded one by one or in fell swoops all the advancement we have made against the cult of death. Embryonic stuff started up today without BO even rescinding Bush's orders!

Two things in about 3 days.....and so it goes. The emergent church needs to rethink because the blood is on their hands too.

RubberChickenGirl

Catherine R. said...

I linked to this post on my Facebook. Indeed, by Obama's own logic, shouldn't his mother have made a better "choice"?

Foolish foolish man.

Claire said...

Lord God, have mercy on our nation!!

Melanie said...

If this isn't domestic terrorism then I don't know what is.

Allison said...

I'm just so disheartened. I almost cried when I read that today :(

Anonymous said...

I can't express how disappointed I am in our new president. My heart aches for the numerous women who might be negatively affected. It is simply terrible! :(

Rebecca said...

If this isn't domestic terrorism then I don't know what is.

Maybe this.

Gombojav Tribe said...

Don't know what your point is, Rebecaa. The article no more changes the cause or argument than this changes yours:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feminists_for_Life

Rebecca said...

I'd argue that abortion clearly does not meet the definition of terrorism (which has become a catch-all for Stuff We Don't Like) - an abortion is not intended to cause fear and is not perpetrated towards any ideological goal. Whereas Mr. Rudolph's actions clearly do meet that definition - he intended, by causing fear in doctors and women, to prevent them from having abortions. (He killed two people, by the way, and injured over one hundred others. Very pro-life of him.)

Likewise I'm not sure what you're trying to convey with your link.

Gombojav Tribe said...

You call yourself a feminist and the group with the link I provided call themselves feminists. That doesn't mean that you see the issues the same, approach them the same way or come to the same conclusions.

Likewise with the link you provided. We're against abortion and so is this terrorist. That doesn't mean that we see the issue the same, approach them the same way or that we come to the same conclusions.

And to your point above, I wholeheartedly disagree. Abortion does cause fear and it is perpetrated towards an ideological goal.

The history of abortion in this country and many others is rooted in eugenics and is still practiced that way despite what you may think.

Rebecca said...

True, but I'm still not sure how that's relevant. I never meant to imply that you condone the terrorist's actions.

When a woman - one woman, not the pro-choice movement as a whole - has an abortion, precisely what ideological goal is she acting towards and in whom is she causing fear?

And while it's true that some early proponents of abortion had a racist or ablist goal in mind, it doesn't mean, as you say, that "we see the issues the same, approach them the same way or that we come to the same conclusions." :) You'll find almost no one in the United States today advocating for abortion - ie. we would like more of it. We prefer choice - ie. we would like the pregnant woman to be able to decide whether or not she wants to have the child. That's why people who are pro-choice also fight for better healthcare for children and for benefits for mothers - so that if a woman chooses to give birth, she will have the resources to care for the child.

I understand by eugenics you're referring to the abortion of fetuses with diseases such as Down's syndrome? I truly doubt that women who abort in such cases do so out of any kind of repugnance for a disabled child. Do you know the kind of labor it takes, over and above the regular amount, to raise a special-needs child? The amount of money? If a woman knows she will not be able to give the child a good life, who knows better than she does?

Gombojav Tribe said...

When a woman has an abortion what ideological goal is she acting towards and in whom is she causing fear? The answer is blatantly obvious. She is acting towards the ideological goal that life is dispensable and she is causing fear in her child. (Not to mention fear in herself. I have counselled many women suffering from post-abortion trauma.)

And I do find people in the United States today who push for more abortions. It's big business.

And before you go down the road of "Do you know what it takes to raise a special-needs child?" as some sort of justification for killing that child, I'd advise you to stop. I'm passionate about a few things and loving those who are disabled or different is one of them. I certainly do know what it takes. My family cared for and nearly adopted (but she was placed with someone else) a beautiful little girl with cerebal palsy, confined to a wheelchair to this day. A little boy with Downe Syndrome forever changed my life (http://gombojav.blogspot.com/2007/01/phillip-lechuga.html) and his mother's grace inspires me everyday. I have a grandfather who is mentally ill and I love him deeply. He's lived with my family since I was a teenager and our lives are better for it.

"Who knows better than she does?" Indeed. Perhaps nature does. Perhaps God does, if you believe in God. Perhaps a world without the disabled is a world not really worth living in. We need those who are "different" as much as they need us.

Gombojav Tribe said...

Rebecca,

I did not approve your last comment. I think I've been more than gracious to keep publishing them. (This is my family blog, not a debate forum, after all.) But, when you start throwing around "stupid" and such I think you've moved passed debate.

GK Chesterton wrote: "People generally quarrel because they cannot argue."

You can rewrite it in a better tone and post again if you'd like. Your choice. (See, I'm not anti-choice! :-) )

Please don't misunderstand me. I've enjoyed our banter! But, let's be civil, shall we?

But, let me just say, that my belief in caring for those different than others has nothing to do with my financial ability to do so. In case you missed it, I live in the ghetto and live well below the "poverty level." As the old saying goes, "Where there's a will there's a way."

My convictions are my convictions despite my circumstances. If convictions are dependent on circumstances they should be called prefrences.

Lady Dorothy said...

I just have to respond to Rebecca saying, "I understand by eugenics you're referring to the abortion of fetuses with diseases such as Down's syndrome? I truly doubt that women who abort in such cases do so out of any kind of repugnance for a disabled child. Do you know the kind of labor it takes, over and above the regular amount, to raise a special-needs child? The amount of money? If a woman knows she will not be able to give the child a good life, who knows better than she does?"

However, I'm not sure I can in one comment. There are too many issues raised in this small paragraph!

Actually, when I hear or speak of eugenics, I don't naturally think of things like Down Syndrome. I may, but usually the first thing that comes to mind is indeed race. I get the idea from those spouting abortion ideals for the poor that it is their solution to poverty. Rid ourselves of the poor (usually black) by killing off their babies. If the poor minorities have a negative population growth factor, we will eventually rid ourselves of them, right?

If a mother does not feel she can provide "a good life", she is not faced with only two options -- living on the streets with a disabled child (which really wouldn't happen with what our government provides) or killing said child. There are many people who would love to give that baby a home. Adoption is another choice -- a great choice.

And, yes, there are women who do find it repugnant to face a disabled child. Just as there are women who would abort because their child is not of the "right" gender or coming at the "right" time. Just as there are women who would kill their just-born child because of some "fault" it has and presidents who say that is a valid medical procedure to do so.

Rebecca said...

Ugh, I had my whole comment typed out and my internet crashed! :( Let's try this again.

Gombojav Tribe:

I referred to that belief as "stupid" in the sincere conviction that you did not hold it. I was convinced I must be mistaken, because I just can't understand why anyone would believe that, and I was hoping to be proven right. I apologize for coming across badly.

(I too am enjoying our chat! It's always interesting to hear what someone with a completely opposite viewpoint has to say. You're welcome to come by my blog if you like - Brian and I are very busy so we don't often make long posts, but we try.)

In any case. The answer is blatantly obvious. She is acting towards the ideological goal that life is dispensable and she is causing fear in her child.
Which child would this be? At the time the vast majority of abortions take place, the embryo is months away from developing even the capacity for consciousness, let alone fear.

As for "the ideological goal that life is dispensable" - I'll assume you meant what I think you mean, since that doesn't make grammatical sense, and ask: how is she working towards this goal? How does her abortion affect anyone but herself and those close to her?

Who would these people pushing for more abortions be?

And it's wonderful that you do that. Really, it is. I'm vaguely offended, though, by the suggestion that a woman bring a disabled child into the world as a favor to other people. It's quite true that everyone around her might benefit from knowing and loving a disabled person, but that doesn't change the fact that at the heart of the matter it is she who gives birth to the child and who bears the primary burden of taking care of him/her.

Perhaps. But it's not nature or God trying to stop her having an abortion - it's officials in government and other people who don't know anything about her or her circumstances.

The belief that I earlier referred to as "stupid" and that I will now call "misguided" is the belief that one woman, having an abortion because she cannot give a disabled child the kind of life it deserves, is somehow indicative of a grand plot to rid the world of disabled people. Plenty of women - plenty of pro-choice women, in fact - choose to give birth to children with special needs because they want the child and know they are up to the task. I don't think you truly believe that we are part of a eugenics scheme, and I was hoping you'd clarify what you meant.

Lady Dorothy:

As you wish. I wasn't sure if our gracious host was referring to race or disability, suspected the latter, and went with that, but I can discuss race as well.

I am, of course, aware that the minority abortion rate in the United States far surpasses the white abortion rate. But it's not as if doctors are lurking in the shadows waiting to snatch pregnant women of color off the street! When financial straits are the most common motive for abortion, and minorities are disproportionately poor, it stands to reason that women of color would have more abortions. The way to solve this problem is by giving them the opportunity to get an education and a good job, not burdening them with more children and continuing the cycle of poverty. (Better and cheaper childcare facilities in the workplace and schools would also help.)

You're making an all-too-common mistake in assuming that the child will definitely find a home. A white, healthy child, yes. A child of a minority race or with a physical or mental disability has a much harder time being placed in a family. Too many children age out of foster care without ever having a home - I believe the figure is about twenty thousand a year. Knowing this, how is it possible to say there is a shortage of children to adopt? (In the United States, to say nothing of abroad.)

Oh, please. There's a difference between a child with Down's syndrome or cerebral palsy and one with no brain. An anencephalic baby is not going to live anyway; it would seem like the humane thing to do to to perform an abortion rather than prolong its life for a few hours of agony before inevitable death. (That is the sort of thing that BAIPA and PBABA concern themselves with - pregnancies that go wrong late in the term, almost always wanted children, where it is kinder and safer to all concerned to abort.)


(All this apart from actual arguments in favor of reproductive choice, which I can provide if either of you would like to hear.)

Gombojav Tribe said...

Rebecca,

So you don't believe that children in the womb can feel pain, anxiety,fear, etc. I could not disagree more!

I am a certified childbirth educator and doula so have researched this particular topic. I have also walked with many women through pregnancies and have been at many births. As a mother of six myself, I have a little experience in this area.

Babies absolutely have emotions.
One way this can be seen is in their heart rates. When a mother is relaxed and calm the baby's heart rate is steady. Then if the mother thinks of something distressing and troublesome the heart rate of the baby drops dramatically. When the mother clears her mind and thinks of something pleasant and is calm again, the baby's heart rate returns to it's beginning rate.

In addition studies have shown that anxiety in mothers lead to low-birth rate babies.

It has also been proven that babies feel pain in the womb.

Abortion is violence at it's worst! It's violence against a child who was conceived through no fault of his/her own. It's violence against women. It perpetrates violence in society.

The idea that life is dispensable is a very advantageous thing to promote for socialists and communists or any group that wants to have control over another group without questioning. It's a way to manipulate masses. Abortion serves that end.

Who would the people be that are pushing for more abortions? Well, people who are pushing for FOCA.

This legislation would repeal all regulation (state, local and federal) of abortion. In fact, FOCA is very anti-choice, despite what "pro-choice" people say.

For example there's a law in, I believe, South Dakota that made the ultrasound screen face a woman who was considering abortion, thus giving her INFORMED CHOICE. This common sense law would be overturned if FOCA passes, allowing sound medical information to be withheld from a patient. This is a violation of a patient's rights!

Senator Brownback authored great legislation that required parents who receive a diagnosis of a disabled child (such as Downe Syndrome) to also receive information about services and support available to them if they decide to carry their baby to term. This common sense law would be overturned if FOCA passes.

The Born Alive Infant Protection Act which merely says that if a child is born alive he/she must be treated as a human would be overturned if FOCA passes.

And so on. Over 500 pieces of legislation would be overturned in one fell swoop--making abortion a federal issue rather than something that should be decided by families, localities and states. I'd say that was pushing for more abortions and is completely anti-choice (and downright unconstitutional!).

And how is "having the life [one] deserves" a prerequisite to having a life at all? Many people are born into rough circumstances, poverty, prejudice, etc. That innocent child doesn't deserve to be born into those circumstances. But, are you saying that if a child isn't born into plenty and wealth with a guarantee of education and success that that child shouldn't live? That's where your argument ends, you know.

"The life it deserves" is a very interesting concept.

I think I'm a pretty good person. I "deserve" a better life. I guess since I can't have the life I deserve maybe I shouldn't have life at all?

My children are awesome. So intuitive and precious, so....just awesome. If you knew them you'd think so too. :-) They "deserve" to live in a great neighborhood where they can ride their bikes in the street and walk to the store without fear of strangers. They each deserve their own room. They deserve new clothes and not hand-me-downs. They deserve to go to college and not to have to put themselves through. They deserve all their hearts' desire.
But because I cannot give them the life they deserve is that justification for not having given them life at all?

Every child is awesome. Even the "damaged" ones. They have something very important and special to offer the world. That child didn't ask to be conceived and therefore should not be denied his/her very basic right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

I read a touching story just today. It had me in tears. You can read it here:
http://yestheyareallmine-mom.blogspot.com/2008/12/she-was-born-just-two-weeks.html

Well, that's all I have time for tonight. I promised my little girl we'd read together before bed.

Goodnight.

Lady Dorothy said...

Rebecca,

You and I have some fundamental differences that are very great that. I doubt there will be any common ground. I come from the foundational standpoint that life comes from God and is indeed the breath of God. Nothing trumps that.

I believe that abortion is murder. Plain and simple. No way around that in my mind nor in my heart. Murder should never be a choice. I do not believe that people should get a choice to kill their neighbor, no matter how good their reasons are. In the same manner, I do not think that people should get a choice to kill their child.

And I do not believe that I am personally responsible for taking care of them or their child if they do not get an abortion in the same way that I am not responsible for what their neighbor does if they do not kill him. How silly that would be. (Do I believe in helping? Do I help? Yes and yes.)

I do not believe that financial straits are the most common motive for abortion. I believe that anyone in the United States can get an education if they want one. I do not believe that “better and cheaper” childcare is the answer to abortion. I have a great many reasons to believe these things – mostly derived from experience dealing with people for a great many years in and of all walks of life and with most of the problems one can even try to think up .

I grew up in a home that provided foster care to children waiting to be adopted. My daughter is currently in the process of adopting. My husband and I have also tried to adopt. The statistics are not new to me. I am not making the assumption that every child will find a home. Unfortunately, that will not happen. But, it will not be because there are not people wanting them. It will be because of bureaucracy. If our government funded adoption with the same fervor that they do abortion, the children would not grow up without a family.

Where did you get the idea that partial birth abortions and infanticide are only performed on children that are going to die anyway? That is so not the case. (You don’t need to search very far at all to find personal testimonies to prove this not true.) But if it was, why do we feel the need to kill them first? Would there be any agony if the child had no brain? Your argument seems to trip over itself.

Well, this is a very long comment. I might as well sign off now.

Rebecca said...

Gombojav Tribe:

Could you provide me with data on that? Every study I've read shows that the brain is just not sophisticated enough at that stage to feel pain or fear. I believe it's not even until twenty-five weeks or later that the senses even begin to develop, but I could be misremembering.

Ah, I get what you're saying now. (that, rather than acting towards an ideological goal, she's buying into a particular worldview?) But I'd emphatically disagree that it's only socialists and communists that want to make people into sheep! It's a common tactic with both atheist groups like socialists and communists and religious groups like certain churches. Most pro-lifers I know, for example, argue that abortion is bad because God opposes murder, but only because their religious leaders tell them so and without thinking about it for themselves, ignoring the vast number of murders God commits or orders in the Bible. (I'm not meaning this as a slur on you - I don't know you well enough to put you in any category.) I think we can agree that thinking for oneself is always a positive. :)

As for the ultrasound law - I think a woman should always be informed about her choices. (When she carries to term, too.) My concern is mainly the script that South Dakota (and, I believe, Oklahoma as well) mandates that doctors have to read to women seeking abortions. A script written by politicians, not by doctors, and full of lies. Freedom of choice, this?

I'm not sure why you'd say that FOCA would overturn the Kennedy-Brownback bill. It's not a restriction on abortion. Likewise, BAIPA is largely a symbolic law and even has a clause that states it won't be used to restrict abortion rights - unlikely to go.

The federalism argument is disingenuous - were you not pleased when the federal government banned D&X?

But anyway. I reject your argument that people promoting FOCA are in favor of abortion. True, removing restrictions on abortion would allow women who want abortions and who are denied them to have them, but that's choice. No one's going out urging anyone to have abortions or forcing them on people who don't want them.

I admit I can't speak with any great eloquence or experience on "the life it deserves" - I do not plan to have children, and if I were to give birth I would give the child up for adoption, so while it's a terrible decision to have to make, it's not one I expect to have to face. I guess it really comes down to this: it's her body. If she does not feel that she can raise a child - it's her body. The idea that anyone other than herself can have a right to her body is absolutely chilling. That goes beyond socialism.

But yes, if only...

Enjoy your time with your daughter. :) What are you reading together?

Lady Dorothy:

Indeed we have fundamental differences. I hope we can still talk like civilized people though.

You talk about not wanting to be personally responsible for others or their children. You don't want your hard-earned money going to them. (My apologies if I am misrepresenting your views.) In short, you seem to believe strongly in your individual right to your property. I, too, believe in individual rights, and just how much more fundamental to everything we hold dear is the right to one's own body? As I said above in response to Gombojav Tribe, the idea that someone's right to control what goes on inside his or her own body is not absolute is quite frightening.

What, then, do you believe is the most common motive for abortion, and could you cite a survey or two? (I'm going by the Guttmacher study and a couple of others.) I admire your optimism, but it is truly difficult for poor people in America to get the same quality education as middle-class or rich people. University completely aside - if you can't afford a computer, or have to work instead of studying, for example, it becomes increasingly hard to get a good education.

The government doesn't fund abortion - that is illegal. (Hyde Amendment)

If you look at it logically, there's no real reason to have a D&X unless there's a severe health issue. If a woman just doesn't want a child, period, she can abort in the first or second trimester before the embryo/fetus is even viable. (Down's is also diagnosed before viability.) If she's carried it long enough that it's viable, she, as a reasonable human being, is not just going to decide she doesn't feel like being pregnant anymore, after she's had morning sickness for months and after those around her have started to comment on her baby bump. These are wanted pregnancies. If she develops a health problem but the fetus is sound, she can have a C-section. If a defect incompatible with life is discovered or if the fetus has in fact died, these are the cases where a D&X is performed.

As for anencephaly and pain - good point. I realize I've conflated several disorders into one. (This is why I should not comment on blogs while running back and forth from the kitchen.) In the particular case of anencephaly, though, since as stated above the child will die, it is far less painful to the mother, if not to the child, to perform a (currently illegal) D&X - this collapses the skull, so it is easier to push out.

Right, time for bed.

Lady Dorothy said...

Rebecca:

You read a lot into what someone says. I did not say I did not want my money to help others. But, you are right that I don’t think that I’m so stupid that they have to tell me where to give by taking it from me and giving it for me.

I do believe in the right to one’s own body. That is why I think abortion is such an atrocity. I believe the baby is a living human being – one who has the right to her own body!

A woman has a choice to not have a baby living inside her. No one is taking that choice from her. She makes that choice when she has sexual intercourse. She should not have the choice to kill another living being once she has made the risky choice to do the very thing that makes that life. Every time we make a choice in life, we close doors to other choices. That’s basic.

I am not going to cite a survey. Any student of statistics knows that you can make numbers say what you want. I already said that my experience is what I based by statements on. I believe the most common motives for abortion are selfishness, convenience, ignorance, and fear.

I did not try to compare quality of education of the poor, middle-class, or rich. I just stated that an education is available if you desire one. Yes, maybe the desire has to stronger for some than others, but the opportunity is still there. As one who worked throughout her “education years” (quotes used only because I really don’t believe that learning should ever be over) and often more than one job, I understand that it makes the time not quite as fun as we somehow think those years should be. But, if one is truly going for an education, it can be had. If one is aiming for the “college experience”, who knows?

“The government doesn't fund abortion - that is illegal. (Hyde Amendment)” Ah, and how many loopholes are there argued every year in Congress to get around this? And how many States are under court orders to do this very thing? And our President just overturned an Executive Order in order to do this very thing around the world!

”If you look at it logically, there's no real reason to have a D&X unless there's a severe health issue.” I will agree with this if we take off “unless there’s a severe health issue.” There is never a REAL reason to suck the brains out of a human being. Easier to push out? If a birth has progressed to this point, the head coming out is not really an issue. Seriously. I have been present at twelve natural vaginal births. It isn’t. Besides, those shoulders are wider than the head. Oh, yeah, we break apart their bones, too, huh?

As to some things you mentioned to Daja, why do you think FOCA will only overturn some rulings? Who is going to pick and choose? The exact wording is: “This Act applies to every Federal, State, and local statute, ordinance, regulation, administrative order, decision, policy, practice, or other action enacted, adopted, or implemented before, on, or after the date of enactment of this Act.”

Gombojav Tribe said...

Rebecca:

I will blog about babies experiencing pain and emotions in the womb in another post in the near(ish) future. So look for that.

As to abortion being wrong because it's murder, yet God orders murder in the Bible....this argument shows a lack of understanding about abortion and the Bible! (Do you not believe that murder is wrong or do you not believe that a baby is a human?) First of all, if you would have read in my Being ProLife post, you would know, as with many prolifers we are pro-life not just anti-abortion. This means that we stand for life over death anytime there is a face-off between the two. Second of all, as for Biblical incidences, you are confusing killing with murder. As unpleasant the possibility is, all killing is not murder. If someone is attacking me and I take my handy cast-iron skillet to their head and they die, I have not murdered them. I have defended myself. If there is a car accident and someone dies, that is not murder, although we say, "He was killed in a car accident." Inevitable deaths in unfortunate wars are not necessarily murders. I don't know what Biblical incidences you are speaking of, but just to clarify, God is a God of Life. Jesus called Himself the way, the truth and the life. That's who He is.

You say you want a woman to have all her choices and yet you support the FOCA which would take away a woman's informational access all her choices. You're fooling yourself if you think the ultrasound laws and information about alternatives to abortion will not be overturned. All laws that help to reduce the number of abortions will be overturned. It's a terribly broad and ill-thought-out piece of legislation.

The federalism argument is not disingenuous. My how you like to dismiss facts you don't like by calling them stupid, misguided or disingenuous! The federal government had no business legalizing abortion in the first place. And now they have no right to override a state's regulation of it.

I agree with you that a woman should have a right to her body. However, a baby is not her body. The baby has it's own DNA completely separate from her mother. A mother and baby do not share blood or blood type. The baby is a separate person. A woman may have a right to do what she wants with her own body--she can sleep with every man who walks by if she wants. But, she does not have the right to take the life of another.

The fact that the baby is inside her is beside the point. Rhetoric such as her body being used as an incubator or someone else having a right to her body make it sound as if she was abducted by aliens and impregnated against her will! Come on! That baby did not ask to be there, having that baby there was the WOMAN'S CHOICE and a child should not take the punishment for another's poor decision. If a mother does not feel she can raise a child she can give it up for adoption. No one is making her be a parent. I fail to see that killing a child is somehow an option.

And let's not use the health of the baby (babies with no brains and the like) or health of the mother (I've given birth to six kids, I do know what it takes!) as some sort of smoke screen here. 98% of abortions in the United States are personal choice (unwanted or inconvenient pregnancies). 1.7% are for the life/health of the mother or child. And .3% are for rape/incest. And even before Roe v. Wade abortion was legal in cases of the mother's life in danger. I'm tired of those 2% of cases being used to justify the 98% of cases!

And despite the Hyde Ammendment, many are tax-payer funded.

"In April, the annual report of Planned Parenthood Federation of America revealed that the abortion giant had a total income of $1.02 billion--with reported profits of nearly $115 million. Taxpayers kick in more than $336 million worth of government grants and contracts at both the state and federal levels. That's a third of Planned Parenthood's budget. And what market-distorting results do we get for those government incentives? 289,650 abortions in 2006." (from Planned Parenthood's obscene profits by Michelle Malkin Creators Syndicate Copyrights 2008.)

Rebecca said...

Lady Dorothy:

My apologies, I should have been more clear. Of course it's not that you don't want your money to help others (if you didn't, why would you give to charity?) but rather that you see its disposal as your prerogative rather than anyone else's. Is that more accurate?

Although the embryo/fetus has its own body, it's still inside the woman's body, and she has the right not to have it inside her. Imagine applying the logic you use to any other scenario - "A family has a choice to maintain the safety of their home. No one is taking that choice from them. They make a choice to invite a friend into their home. They should not have the choice to eject him for eating them out of house and home and threatening their children once they have made the risky choice to do the very thing that allowed him to come inside. Every time we make a choice in life, we close doors to other choices."

I'm interested in hearing what you'll say to this question, just because people have so many different positions on it: would you allow a woman to have an abortion if she had been raped?

Three-fourths of people checking a box that says finances were a motivating factor in their choice of abortion is "[making] numbers say what you want"? As you wish. Though I'd ask you how you'd define "convenience" in a way that does not include financial situation.

I think we'll just have to disagree here. I know too many people who had to drop out for financial reasons to accept that it's just a question of "fun." (As for the college experience - way too many jobs require degrees when they're not really necessary, which makes it harder for the less well-off to get those jobs. The UK is much more sensible about that.)

I'll have to repeat your question back to you - how many loopholes are there argued every year in Congress to get around this? How many states are under court orders to do this very thing? (Ah, didn't realize you were referring to the overturn of the global gag rule as well as domestic law. Thankfully, that money goes mainly to birth control and education, which should reduce the number of abortions. Not to mention that a lot of organizations that were stripped of funding didn't even provide abortions - mentioning abortion was enough.)

If it's the method itself you have a problem with, D&E is both more "inhumane" to the fetus and more dangerous for the woman.

Good job, you've quoted the last section of the Act correctly. Don't forget the most important part, though, which states, "A government may not deny or interfere with a woman's right to choose to bear a child, to terminate a pregnancy prior to viability, [or] to terminate a pregnancy after viability where termination is necessary to protect the life or health of the woman; or discriminate against the exercise of the rights set forth...in the regulation or provision of benefits, facilities, services, or information." Why would a bill that does not restrict abortion or discriminate against women seeking abortion be affected?

Rebecca said...

Gombojav Tribe:

Thanks. I will.

I do believe that murder is wrong. Personally, I don't believe that an embryo with no capacity for consciousness is a person, but that's irrelevant to my general argument, which is that it's the woman's body and it's her call what happens inside it.

And that's another way you're different from those pro-lifers in my area I was talking about. They cry out against abortion, yet don't seem to see any irony or inconsistency in supporting the death penalty or aggressive war! They are cah-razy.

As for murder in the Bible - a few instances that come to mind without looking into my Bible are the tenth plague (killed all the first-born males, even little children, because one man, the Pharaoh, would not free the Hebrews) - not self-defense, not an accident, not war. God kills David and Bathsheba's first child as a punishment to them for their adultery - not self-defense, not an accident, not war. Elisha curses a bunch of children for making fun of his baldness, and God sends bears to eat them - not self-defense, not an accident, not war. (Yes, I remember this one because it's bizarre.)

A woman can always ask to view the ultrasound if she chooses. Just as she can ask to view an endoscopy, though it isn't mandated by law that she do so. She is being denied no information.

So if a state wants to allow "partial-birth abortion," should it be allowed to do so, since the federal government had no business banning it?

It's not beside the point at all. If she is being forced to use her body to house someone else, her right to her body is being overridden by that other entity's.

I gather by this that you'd allow abortion for a woman who was raped?

I have no intention of using either as a smoke screen. I am perfectly honest about my justification for why abortion should be legal. (If you've forgotten, that's it's her body.) But I still find it horrible that the PBABA has no health exception and that in the minds of many it's OK for a rapist to keep violating his victim's body for nine months through a pregnancy.

Planned Parenthood is not allowed to use that money for abortion, and I'm sure you'd find more accurate information if you looked at a source that wasn't Michelle Malkin! Birth control, STD testing, and education are certainly worth taxpayer money.

Gombojav Tribe said...

Rebecca:

I don't know what "blue" area you live where all the pro-lifers are so different from me! I live in one of the most liberal "blue" counties in the country.

I think you perhaps have pro-lifers in a very small box. You have lots of preconceived ideas that could use the light of reality. It is not that I am so different in standing for life against death every time there is face-off between the two. The "Pro-Life Rosary" which is prayed by Catholics all over the world every day says: "Lord, I offer these three Hail Mary's for an increase in Faith, Hope, and Love in all people so that all people will always choose life, and I also offer them in reparation for the suffering you endure each time an unborn babe is killed, each time someone is euthanized, each time death overcome life in this world. Amen." (The whole rosary can be read here: http://premier.net/~avemarie/pro-life.htm)

For this reason (that I am pro-life and not just anti-abortion) I do not support abortion in the case of rape. (Which accounts for .3%, so is not a reason to keep abortion legal in all cases and throught all nine months of pregnancy!) That baby is still not at fault. Two wrongs don't make a right. I fail to see why a child should bear the punishment of its father. This also comes from my faith, which says that a child shall not bear the sin of the father. (Ezekiel 18:20)

As for the Biblical references you mentioned....interesting choices. All those cases are stories of people who died of a supernatural cause attributed to God. That's not murder or killing. If I were to just die right now, no one would say she was killed or murdered. It would be called an "Act of God" which has never been synonymous with murder.

The Christian belief is that God knows the number of our days. When they are up, they are up. That's why the Bible tells says, "Teach me, Lord, to number my days that I might gain a heart of wisdom."

On to your other points....

You say that a woman is not denied any meidcal information. That is not true. I am a doula and have been at many births and doctor appointments with clients. I have seen first hand medical information withheld from women. As a birth professional, I have had to step in and be an advocate for the mother and child and ask that all the information be given her. I've had doctors and nurses feign ignorance and act like they can't find the package insert to the drug they are pushing. If this happens in pregnancies and births where the intention is to KEEP the baby, do you think this doesn't happen when one is planning to abort a baby? I am not that naive.

"The patient did not ask for the information" is not a legal justification for not giving someone all the information. It does not hold up in court. The legal definiation of "Informed Consent" means all the information is given to the patient regardless of whether he/she asks for it.

And one last point: "Birth control, STD testing, and education are certainly worth taxpayer money."

Let's look at this......

Sex without the intent to produce a child is recreation. It's not a right, it's completely recreational. Why should tax-payer money go to provide someone with birth control so they can have recreational sex? No one pays me to play tennis on the weekend or to watch TV all day Saturday. No one pays me to crochet or to go to the park or have a glass of wine. Why in the world should someone pay for me to get laid on the weekend? Seriously, that is just completely illogical.

You quote to Lady Dorothy from FOCA, "A government may not deny or interfere with a woman's right to choose to bear a child, to terminate a pregnancy prior to viability..."

How is the law for when a child is viable decided? It changes all the time. Not that long ago it was unthinkable to save babies that are daily saved now. Babies are now considered viable as early as 20 weeks. Meaning, they can, with proper care, survive outside the womb! Yet, it is still legal to kill the child at that stage.

"Viability" is not a constant. With medical advances this changes all the time! Does it suddenly make the baby less of a human at 19 weeks and six days?

Lady Dorothy said...

Rebecca:

This will be my last comment on this post. Not my last entry into a debate on the subject, but my last comment on this post. It has been interesting “talking” to you.

To be honest, I thought your last response was very condescending. As in, “Good job, you've quoted the last section of the Act correctly.”

You wrote: “Although the embryo/fetus has its own body, it's still inside the woman's body, and she has the right not to have it inside her.” Your scenario of a family inviting a friend to stay in the home is an odd one. So, they are tired of him being in their home. They do not then have the right to KILL him!

I am not in the position of “allowing” anyone to have/not have an abortion. But, since I believe that life is God-given (and can be God-taken and should only be God-taken), no, I do not condone abortion in the case of rape. Do I think it a horrendous situation? Yes. However, it is one that doesn’t happen often as pro-abortion advocates want us to believe. Our bodies somehow keep that from happening, whether it is from fear, tension, or something on the male’s part. Does it happen? Yes. But, it is still life and not our right to kill it. Two wrongs do not make it right. If aborted, the woman will then have TWO horrible traumas to deal with. If aborted, the pain of the rape will not go away any faster than if she carries the baby to full term. In real life, that baby has sometimes been the healing factor.

Financial reasons, as you seem to state it, are very relative. Perhaps someone has to drop out of their private school because of financial straits, but they can still get an education at their local junior college. And, yes, when it comes to obtaining a job, a college education nowadays is the equivalent of a high school diploma a few years back. And often in actual knowledge, even less.

As to checking a box as to why one is getting an abortion, how much easier and politically correct to check a box saying finances are the reason, than to say my boyfriend will beat me up, my husband will leave me if I have any more kids, I want to go to beauty school before I have kids, I don’t like kids, I want to make a lot of money before I think of a family, I don’t know who the father is, my boyfriend will make a horrible father, I’m a crack-addict………

“Why would a bill that does not restrict abortion or discriminate against women seeking abortion be affected?” I think you need to think a bit more about this and/or look further into it. Restricting abortion and discrimination are very broad terms that can be used for many things. Just one example: One of the laws that would be repealed is that abortions can only be performed by a qualified physician. Otherwise, according to some, it would be restricting abortion. After FOCA, a social worker (or anyone for that matter!) can perform an abortion! Let’s go back to the back-alley days! And this time, with no penalties!

Gombojav Tribe said...

Thank you, Rebecca and Lady Dorothy for the very interesting discussion and debate.

At this time, because of my own time restraints, I am going to close the comments on this particular post. Feel free to keep commmenting on other blog posts. I hope you keep visiting this blog and I look foward to future dialogue. I'm sure there will be issues on which I will disagree with both of you in the future. Good times.

Off to have grilled cheese with my children and to do some school work.

Blessings on your day and we'll "see" you in blogsphere again, I hope!